Introduction
Welcome to Gain Consulting's latest analysis on the U.S. freight market dynamics. As we approach mid-2025, stakeholders in the logistics and supply chain sectors are keenly observing signs that might indicate the end of the current freight recession. Here, we delve into the latest trends, forecasts, and strategic considerations for U.S. shippers.
Current Market Sentiment: Wait-and-See
The mood among U.S. freight stakeholders can best be described as "wait-and-see." Both intermodal and truckload carriers are sensing a shift, with many believing that shippers are making a last-ditch effort to secure lower contract rates before an anticipated market turnaround this summer. However, skepticism persists, fueled by repeated unfulfilled predictions of market recovery over the past year.
Recent Projections: The most recent forecast from November did not materialize, leaving shippers with significant leverage in the early 2025 contract negotiations. Despite this, there's a consensus that truck capacity has tightened compared to last year.
Signals of Change
Despite the cautious optimism:
Tender Rejection Rates: Derek Leathers from Werner Enterprises highlighted an increase in tender rejection rates, suggesting a rebalancing of capacity and demand. This shift indicates carriers might soon have more pricing power than they've had in recent times.
Economic Forecasts: Breakthrough, a firm known for its predictive analytics in logistics, predicted a market inflection point in mid-2025, which might align with current trends if the earlier part of the year continues to show signs of stabilization.
Shippers' Experience
Not all shippers are feeling the pinch yet:
Stable Rates: Several truckload shippers have managed to negotiate flat rates for 2025 contracts, indicating they haven't yet noticed significant changes in tender rejections or capacity constraints.
Uncertainty: Michael Castagnetto of C.H. Robinson noted the ongoing difficulty in predicting market shifts, with forecasts continuously being adjusted as the industry grapples with post-recession dynamics.
Strategic Pricing and Market Behavior
Gradual Shifts: Knight-Swift's CEO Adam Miller suggests that any pricing power returning to carriers will likely be gradual, akin to pre-pandemic market behaviors rather than the volatile swings seen in recent years.
Intermodal vs. Truckload: Intermodal rates are typically a step behind truckload rates. As truckload rates potentially increase, there might be a shift towards rail for cost savings, though initial 2025 bids for intermodal contracts were not as successful as some intermodal marketing companies (IMCs) hoped.
Competitive Bidding: Companies like J.B. Hunt and Hub Group have maintained aggressive pricing strategies to retain or grow market share, often at the expense of rate increases. Hub Group's Phil Yeager emphasized the importance of volume and service reliability over immediate rate hikes.
Pricing Discipline: Schneider National, on the other hand, has adopted a disciplined approach to pricing, which has resulted in slower volume growth but stable revenue increases, showcasing a strategy focused on long-term profitability rather than short-term gains.
What Shippers Should Consider
For U.S. shippers affiliated with Gain Consulting:
Contract Negotiation: Continue to negotiate contracts with a keen eye on potential rate adjustments. If capacity tightens further, securing favorable terms now could be beneficial.
Diversify Transport Modes: Given the lag in intermodal rates, consider exploring or increasing intermodal options where feasible, especially as truckload rates start to rise.
Market Watch: Keep a close watch on tender rejection rates and capacity signals. These could be early indicators of when to pivot strategies regarding carrier contracts and logistics planning.
Long-term Relationships: Building strong relationships with carriers can be more advantageous than solely focusing on rate reductions. Quality service and reliability might become more critical as the market stabilizes.
Conclusion
The freight market in 2025 is at a crossroads, with signs of recovery on the horizon but no clear consensus on timing. At Gain Consulting, we advocate for a balanced approach, preparing our clients for both scenarios - continued leverage or a shift back towards carriers. Stay informed, stay flexible, and prepare for a market that might soon resemble a more predictable, albeit cautious, new normal.
Comments